Supreme Court Keeps Maryland Gun Restrictions in Place
November 18, 2026 | U.S News
The U.S. Supreme Court has declined to hear a major challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on carrying firearms in designated public locations, leaving the state’s contested gun regulations in place for now.
The decision, issued on November 16, 2026, means that restrictions covering locations such as public transportation, schools, healthcare facilities, public demonstrations and certain recreational areas will continue to stand under the lower court ruling.
The case attracted national attention because it raised an important constitutional question: How far can states go in declaring public locations to be “sensitive places” where people are not allowed to carry firearms?
Although the Supreme Court declined to take up the case, Justice Clarence Thomas issued a separate statement expressing doubts about the historical basis for some of these restrictions. He also indicated that the Court could consider the issue again in a more narrowly focused case.
The decision does not establish a new nationwide gun-carrying rule. Instead, it leaves Maryland’s existing legal framework in place while the broader constitutional debate continues.
What Did the Supreme Court Decide?
The case was known as Novotny v. Moore, involving a challenge to Maryland’s restrictions on carrying firearms in designated sensitive locations.
The Supreme Court declined to grant the petition for a writ of certiorari on November 16. A writ of certiorari is the legal procedure through which the Supreme Court agrees to review a lower court’s decision.
The justices did not provide a detailed explanation for declining the case.
Importantly, refusing to hear an appeal is not the same as issuing a ruling that every challenged provision is constitutionally valid. It means the Supreme Court chose not to review the dispute at this stage.
As a result, the Fourth Circuit’s decision upholding most of the challenged restrictions remains in effect.
The case involved questions about the Second Amendment and the government’s authority to restrict firearm possession in certain public areas.
For Maryland residents, the immediate practical effect is that the restrictions upheld by the appeals court remain applicable, subject to the specific legal status of individual provisions.
Which Places Are Covered by Maryland’s Gun Restrictions?
Maryland has designated several categories of locations where carrying firearms is restricted, including for people who otherwise have permission to carry.
The state’s restrictions cover a range of public spaces and facilities.
Some of the major categories include:
- Government buildings and certain government facilities.
- Public transportation facilities and vehicles.
- Public and private school grounds.
- State parks and forests.
- Museums.
- Healthcare facilities.
- Stadiums, racetracks and amusement parks.
- Casinos and certain recreational locations.
- Locations connected with public demonstrations.
The exact rules depend on the relevant Maryland statute or regulation. Not every location has identical restrictions, and exceptions or separate legal provisions may apply.
Maryland’s Department of State Police has published guidance explaining prohibited firearm-carrying locations and the legal developments affecting enforcement.
The distinction between owning a firearm and carrying it in a particular public place is important. A restriction on carrying a firearm in a designated location does not automatically mean that the person is prohibited from owning a firearm.
Why Did Gun-Rights Advocates Challenge the Law?
The legal challenge centered on the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which protects the right to keep and bear arms.
Gun-rights advocates argued that Maryland had placed too many public locations into the sensitive-places category.
Their position was that states cannot simply declare large numbers of public areas off-limits without showing that the restrictions are consistent with the historical tradition of firearm regulation in the United States.
The legal argument relies heavily on the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen.
In that decision, the Court established a historical-tradition test for evaluating certain firearm regulations. Under that approach, when the government restricts conduct protected by the Second Amendment, it generally must demonstrate that the restriction is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
The Court also recognized that some locations, such as legislative assemblies, polling places and courthouses, have historical connections to firearm restrictions.
However, the definition of a sensitive place has become a major source of disagreement among courts, state governments and gun-rights organizations.
The Maryland case attempted to challenge multiple categories of restrictions together. That broad approach became a significant factor in Justice Thomas’s explanation for why the Supreme Court should not review the case in its current form.
What Did Justice Clarence Thomas Say?
Justice Clarence Thomas issued a separate statement after the Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
Thomas expressed skepticism about whether all of Maryland’s restrictions could be justified under the historical tradition of firearm regulation.
He explained that the Supreme Court’s earlier decisions recognized a limited category of sensitive places where firearms could be prohibited.
However, he warned against expanding that category so broadly that it could undermine the general right to carry firearms in public for self-defense.
Thomas also pointed out that the Maryland challenge involved several different statutes, each raising distinct historical and legal questions.
According to his statement, considering all those restrictions together would make the case more complicated for the Court to review.
He therefore agreed with declining the broad petition while indicating that the Supreme Court should consider the authority of states to regulate firearms in sensitive places through a more narrowly focused case.
His statement is significant because it signals that the constitutional debate is not necessarily over.
However, Thomas’s comments are not a ruling that Maryland’s restrictions are unconstitutional. They represent his individual legal reasoning, not a decision overturning the state’s laws.
How Did the Lower Court Rule?
Before the case reached the Supreme Court, the dispute was considered by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.
In January 2026, the appeals court issued its decision in Kipke v. Moore, addressing multiple challenges to Maryland’s firearm restrictions.
The court upheld most of the challenged location-based restrictions.
The decision examined whether different public locations could legally qualify as sensitive places under the Second Amendment framework.
The Fourth Circuit did not treat every restriction in exactly the same way. Its decision addressed separate categories of locations and included different judicial opinions on particular provisions.
The court also upheld an injunction involving restrictions on carrying firearms in private buildings or property without the owner’s consent.
Maryland’s official guidance subsequently explained which provisions remained enforceable and which were affected by court orders while the Supreme Court review process was pending.
With the Supreme Court declining to hear the appeal, the Fourth Circuit’s ruling remains the controlling decision in this dispute.
Why Is the Decision Important for Other States?
The Maryland case has implications beyond one state because many states have adopted laws identifying locations where firearms cannot be carried.
These laws often cover places such as:
- Public parks and recreational areas.
- Hospitals and medical facilities.
- Bars and businesses serving alcohol.
- Public transportation.
- Stadiums and entertainment venues.
- Government buildings.
- Schools and educational facilities.
States argue that certain locations require additional safety protections because of the nature of the activities taking place there or the people who use those facilities.
Gun-rights advocates, meanwhile, argue that restrictions must have a clear constitutional and historical foundation.
The disagreement is not simply about whether firearms should be allowed in public. It is also about how courts should interpret the Second Amendment when modern state laws cover locations that may not have direct historical equivalents.
The Supreme Court’s decision leaves the current legal disagreement unresolved.
Other states may continue to face lawsuits challenging their own sensitive-place laws. Those cases could eventually produce more focused legal questions for the Supreme Court.
What Happens Next in the Gun-Rights Debate?
The Supreme Court’s decision does not end the wider debate over firearm restrictions in the United States.
One important development is the Court’s scheduled consideration of a separate challenge involving state restrictions on AR-15 rifles and other semiautomatic firearms.
The Court is expected to hear arguments in that dispute on December 2, 2026.
That case involves a different constitutional question from Maryland’s sensitive-places restrictions. It concerns state limits on particular types of firearms rather than the locations where people may carry them.
The distinction matters because the Supreme Court can address different aspects of the Second Amendment through separate cases.
Meanwhile, the Maryland dispute could potentially return to the Supreme Court if litigants bring a more narrowly defined challenge involving a particular restriction.
Justice Thomas’s statement suggests that the Court may be more interested in examining an individual category of sensitive-place restrictions than reviewing a large collection of different laws in one case.
However, there is no guarantee that the Court will accept another challenge or when such a case might reach it.
What Maryland Residents Should Know
For Maryland residents, the most important point is that the Supreme Court’s decision did not remove the state’s firearm restrictions.
People who have a legal permit to carry a firearm should not assume that the decision allows them to carry weapons in locations where state law prohibits it.
The rules can differ depending on the type of location, the applicable statute and any relevant court order.
Residents should consult official state guidance and seek qualified legal advice if they have questions about a specific location or situation.
Maryland’s Department of State Police maintains information about prohibited places and firearm-carrying requirements.
The legal situation can also change if a future court decision addresses a specific restriction.
For now, the Supreme Court’s refusal to review Novotny v. Moore leaves the lower court’s ruling in place.
Conclusion
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to reject the challenge to Maryland’s sensitive-places gun restrictions represents an important development in the ongoing debate over the Second Amendment.
The immediate outcome is clear: the restrictions upheld by the Fourth Circuit remain in place.
But the broader constitutional question remains unsettled. Justice Clarence Thomas’s statement indicates that at least one justice believes the Court should eventually examine whether individual state restrictions fit within the historical tradition of firearm regulation.
The next major developments may come from other Second Amendment cases, including the upcoming dispute over state restrictions on semiautomatic firearms.
For now, Maryland residents must continue following the state’s existing firearm-carrying rules.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Did the Supreme Court strike down Maryland’s gun restrictions?
No. The Supreme Court declined to hear the challenge, leaving the Fourth Circuit’s ruling upholding most of the challenged restrictions in place.
2. When did the Supreme Court make its decision?
The Supreme Court declined to hear Novotny v. Moore on November 16, 2026.
3. What are sensitive places under Maryland law?
They include categories such as schools, public transportation, healthcare facilities, government buildings, state parks, museums and certain entertainment locations.
4. What did Clarence Thomas say about the decision?
Thomas expressed doubts about whether all of Maryland’s restrictions fit the historical tradition of firearm regulation. He suggested that the Court could consider a more narrowly focused challenge in the future.
5. Does the decision affect gun owners in other states?
The decision does not directly change other states’ laws. However, the legal questions surrounding sensitive-place restrictions could influence future Second Amendment cases.
6. Can Maryland residents carry firearms in public?
Maryland residents may carry firearms only in accordance with applicable state and federal laws, including restrictions on specific locations. A permit does not automatically authorize carrying a firearm everywhere.
7. Is the Maryland gun law debate over?
No. The Supreme Court declined this particular challenge, but future lawsuits could raise narrower questions about the constitutionality of individual firearm restrictions.
Sources and References
- Associated Press – Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to Maryland’s sensitive-places gun law.
- U.S. Supreme Court – Novotny v. Moore, No. 25-1324, November 16, 2026.
- Maryland Department of State Police – Prohibited Places to Carry a Firearm.
- Maryland Office of the Attorney General – Statement on the Supreme Court decision.
- Reuters – U.S. Supreme Court sidesteps fight over Maryland’s sensitive-places gun restrictions.
